|
The Age of Shifting
Demographies.
East West Encounter
The word demography
essentially means the branch of knowledge that deals
with human population especially the statistical
analysis of births, deaths, migrations as
illustrating the conditions of life in communities, it
looks at society structurally symmetrical and
asymmetrical. The resonance and the meaning of the
word demography or demographies is taken here from a
sociological trajectory and at another level from the
discipline of population studies. Shifting
demographies looks at the shifting languages, cultures, morphologies, literatures, translations and loss in
translations, of movements backwards and forwards,
patois, hybridity and the binaries which have been an
inherent part of India
From a macro to a micro
level my personal engagements has been with issues
concerning perception, self, gender, sexuality,
identity and representation. Traversing the terrain
of the traditional and the contemporary. My paper also
deals with these issues but looking at these notions
from the visual culture particularly literature,
music and dance which I think are so inextricably
linked within the context of the now the often used
global syndrome, where the deridian difference is
being celebrated more than ever.
On of my favorite
writers Salman Rushdie has famously written ‘Mélange,
hotchpotch,’ he declares, ‘a bit of this and a bit of
that is how newness enters the world’.
‘Its
an intriguing an ambiguous fish, at home in both fresh
and salt water. It migrates thousands of miles to
renegade itself ; it swims against the current rather
that with it ; it risks leaving the water to climb up
rapids and thereby exposes itself to the greedy eyes
of the bears on the banks, hungry for rich pickings ;
and after doing all this, it still has the energy and
cunning to spawn something personal and new. Its
intentions is to return to the wild and salty ocean,
knowing that it has left behind something of value,
and learnt something new on each journey. (Gavin
Jantjes, “the artist as a cultural salmon”)
With the establishment
of the World Trade Organization in 1995, the only
global organization dealing with trade, the world
shrinks and becomes a global village. When apples from
Australia find their way into the local fruit markets
of Delhi, when Tofu from Thailand is available off
the shelf in Hyderabad and Manoj Night Shyamalan of
Indian origin makes the film ‘Sixth Sense’ in the U.S.
and creates a stir in Hollywood. When Mumbai born
Anish Kapoor becomes the British artist for the Venice
Biennale, and when Salman Rushdie and V.S Naipaul, of
Indian origin educated at academies abroad win the
Booker prize and the Nobel prize for literature
respectively the cultural Salmon is
born.
With media culture
becoming increasingly global and a bearer of post
modern forms that seem to travel easily across borders, bring with it a sense of homogeneity - with MTV,
FTV channels regularly telecasting forms of popular
music such as rap, heavy metal, grunge, these styles
becoming analogous the world over. As a result the
Michael Jackson moonwalk is seen on the ‘thelas’
of a ‘subziwala’ in a remote tehsil of
Uttar Pradesh. Both the urban and rural Indian youth
is westernizing itself, cultivating dreadlocks,
wearing, short skirts and tank tops, coloring hair
and using matt make up bringing in a uniform
cosmopolitanism. Imitation of Hollywood stars and
singers go hand in hand with Madonna look alikes on
Indian music videos. This inherent duality, the
ontological paradox becomes a virtual reality.
A new pantheon emerges
where saints, heroes and martyrs, politicians,
screen idols, beauty queens, cricket and tennis
champions are established as the new icons of the day.
Turning the indefinable
edge of the millennium has a particular significance
in the context of a modern Indian art. With the
benefit of a new perspective, the basis of modernism
in India comes in for fresh examination.
Shifting demographies
lead to a shift from the village to the complexities
of psychologies and psycho- analysis, from religious
faith to dialectic materialism, from evolutionary
change to a revolutionary one.
Images change not only
with the politics but with every new climate of
opinion. Going back in time, early 20th
century saw masters like Nandalal Bose reclaiming
classical themes from mythology and literature,
reviving an indigenous sensibility. Amrita Shergil
and Jamini Roy were rediscovering idioms from their
immediate environment and folk art respectively. Raja
Ravi Verma used tradition against western adaptations
which gave rise to new a idiom. It was thus the
marking or the beginning of a ‘modern’ era in Indian
art.
Post colonial India saw
an energy which valorized the context of modernity
with the progressives, where artists like F,N Souza,
S.H. Raza and other members and associates of the
progressive Artist Group helped to give modern art in
India an autonomous status. While at Shantiniketan the
work practice of Nandalal Bose, Ramkinker Baij and
Benodbihari Mukherjee brought through the ruse and
reason of indigenous subject- matter a methodological
shift in constructing the image.
Turning the pages of
history coming closer to the present the 80s, which
begins with a period of narratives of Indian art, the
traditions of K.G. Subramanyam, Buphen Khakkar and
Ghulamohammad Sheikh, we renegotiate several
traditions at once. The intertextualiy of their images, the art historical references, the popular idiom
serve as a more confident affirmation of a regional
and properly differentiated national aesthetic. Art
language now affirms its multivalence, opening up the
ideology of modernism to the possibility of
alternative realities. By its transgressions what is
retroactively called the postmodern impulse opens up
the structure of the artwork, too- neatly placed
within the high culture of modern India. The new
narrators rattle the bars of national tradition and
let out the parodic forces suppressed within it.
A host of new avatars
descended quite suddenly on both the painterly and the
sculptural ground. The decade of the 90s saw the rise
of many representational tendency in sculpture making
a dramatic rupture with modernist conventions and
offered a retake on classical traditions.
The first retake on the
sculptural tradition came from Ravinder Reddy,
Dhruva Mistry and NN Rimzon. Reddys sculpture is
about seduction, ornament, gigantism, iconicity,
repetition, and fetish. Foxed with a burning gaze he
equates the eroticism in the divine and popular, high
and low traditions and thereby putting in a kitsch
sublime. Whereas Dhruv Mistry feels closer to the
metaphysical threshold of the sculptural dimension.
In his work there is a vibrancy of movement of the
corporeal life of the object which is revealed by the
fullness of the surrounding object. His work has an
anatomical accuracy, a formal purity further enhanced
by his sensitivity to light as caught by sculptural
forms. NN Rimzon inspired by German realist and
expressionist figuration of the day, did exaggeratedly
naturalistic and then distorted figures of human
vulnerability and disabling entrapment in wider
situations. His idiom imbibed in a unique manner
elements of the Conceptual and Minimalist attitudes
through which he pared down archetypal imagery in
order to reach the core of things, rudimentary states
and fine qualities of humanism
90s with the young Turks
of Indian artists gained ground and assumed an
authorial confidence to handle multifarious
references. Certain urban Indian artists started being
taken ‘seriously’ by the western curators, their
works being acquired by museums overseas. With the
1971 war with Pakistan, the naxalite movement in
Bengal, and the curtailing of democracy during the
emergency, formed the political backdrop for a new
phase in art, The artists of the cities of Bombay,
Calcutta. New Delhi, Madras, felt it incumbent to
refer to the national situation, to document the pain
of their surroundings. A pre- occupation and the need
for social responsiveness started gaining greater
urgency, leading to a major delineating point of view.
Addressing central issues of subjectivity, urban
angst, memory and mythic materials. This trend became
accentuated with some younger artists, like
Nalini Malini, Sheba Chacchi, Navtoj Altaf, Natraj
Sharma, Shilpa Gupta, Subodh Gupta, Atul Dodiya,
Baiju Parthan Jitish kallat, Sunil Gawde, Shibu
Natesan and Amit Ambalal to name a few in painting. The trend been to revitalize the picture- space by
bringing a variety of pictorial discourses to bear on
its flat surface. These artists propose their
pictorial fictions through a regional contemporaneity
that is assertively framed, especially by reference
to the artistic and curatorial ascendancy of the first
world. Nalini Malini, Navtoj Altaf, Sheba Chacchi
to name a few are discussed as the new installators, Nalini
Malini in hamletmachine a video installation reinterprets
Shakespeare's hamlet in
the present day political context of India, while Sheba
Chacchi in ‘Neelkanth’ installation,
relocates the mythological figure of Neelkanth to the
contemporary Indian city where the basic elements are
all poisoned. Navtoj Altaf ‘Between Memory and
History recalls memory into an image in amaze like
pattern superimposed with text and ribbons. Subodh
Gupta in ‘Vilas’ a photo installation foregrounds
the erotic, while at the same time giving him the
audacious persona of a vagabond from a local wrestling
school. Atul Dodiya, has moved on from his
muted photo- realism of the 1980s to an allegorical
dramatization of his dilemmas as a painter in the
epoch of installation through a series of oblique
self- portraits and witty tableaux. Amit Ambalal
places a caricatural spin on proverb and folk tale, subjecting to wry satire and occasionally puncturing
such venerable figures as yogis and critics. A
refashioning of pictorial fictions through a regional
contemporaneity started becoming visible. Artists like
Baiju Parthan and Jitish Kalat express
themselves though a coded symbolism, a secret
pictorial language that draws, paradoxically, on
public and universal sources of ideas and imagery like
the net itself and science. Their art is marked by a
play with textures of referentiality, the artists take
on questions raised by neurology, genetics, quantum
mechanics and the usage of technology. It becomes
visible in all the visual arts. artists work out
private narratives and public myths in their manifold
mediations: in the medium classical for India -
painting - as well as photography, video, installation
and digital art; combining the national, local, and
global
The artists have all
emerged from the art academies set up by the British
reeking of a colonial baggage embedded in the urban
landscape. What sets the artists apart ? what makes
them ‘interesting’ to the curators from the developed
world. The inclusion of their own culture, their own
identities and the indigenenous styles of
representation., working through quotage,
appropriation and wit, their allegories reclaim an
Indian route to post- modernism.
On the other hand with
discursive spaces opening up and traversing
trajectories the Indian diasporas one such multilayer
are gaining ground, regaining their traditions and
exploring and making interventions into the same are
the British born Indian artists -the twin sisters
Amrit and Rabindra Kaur, who are essentially drawing
on the Indian miniature tradition while combining in
it western and eastern aesthetics to create a unique
genre in the British art practice. Challenging
existing stereotypes and redefining narrow perception
of heritage and identity.
The artistic
development we see today is an interplay between irony
and contemplation, playfulness and critique. In each
line of development, i.e. sculpture, painting,
graphic, we see that the availability of new media,
materials and technologies has brought about a number
of innovations in the form and framing of the artwork
and in the manner in which artists now play response-
expectation circuitry of the audience.
All arrive at the same
issues : the question of either personal or political
identities; the creation of new communities ; the
dynamic redefinition of art practices in relation to
cultural change; the dialogue between the poetic and
the technological dimensions of art. The artists work
up a friction between the cosmopolitan and the local,
between classical iconography and vernacular imagery.
In the process, they create new forms and practices
that stand on the threshold between the conventional
art and the ever changing public sphere. Whether it is
studio painting, the sculpture- installation, the
internet or the public domain, it is the above which
becomes the locus of the new Indian art. Artists are
working with the same basic operative variables. They
seek new sites for their non- conventional art
practices, new art situations beyond the purview of
the established studio-gallery - museum spaces. They
also attempt to develop new forms of response to their
new sites and languages of art- making, acknowledging
that conventionally trained or conditioned viewers are
baffled by their art works and require the mediation
of dialogue in order to engage with the new art
idioms. Process and its temporality replace the
durable art objects, thus critically examining the
notion of ‘timeless art’. Video art has brought a new
means of expression to Indian artists. These artists
are not video artists per se, but rather painters,
sculptors, installation artists and photographers. As
video becomes a means for telling the larger story and
examining the change and crisis that confront us on
many levels, artists are using it to critically
interrogate the reality they live in. This innovative
appearance in visual culture has come to be applied
with many art forms, the big idea of bringing
together the dispersed elements in a fresh ensemble
making of assembled works. A reliance on
interdisciplinary skills in a collaboration with
heterogeneous materials. As a medium Installation and
video art generally uses space as an element designed
to be entered into a part of the process of
experience. This has led to the shift of art beyond
the confines of the gallery environment, the
involvement of location has invoked associations of
site specificity as its social history, identity and
belonging enter the work of artists. The euphoric
marriage between art and technology invokes a never
before, the experience of interactivity,
transparency, dematerialization, penetrability and
mobility.
The importance of
lens-based work, specifically photography, in the
enterprise of finding an interface between documentary
‘evidence’ and the social imaginary gaining ground in
this new age. In India, photography entered the
artist’s basic vocabulary in the 1990s. Even for
itself, photography may be said to have enlarged its
intrinsic value as an art form - of being, as it were,
an ‘imprint’ of the real - by entering the expanded
frame of installation art, whether this is
object-based or sculptural ensemble, or video and new
media installation. Thus photography begins to share
the peculiarity of the phenomenological encounter that
the museum/gallery space encourages. Particularly in
combination with video, it acquires a kind of
contingency value: there is a loss in so far as its
insistence on authenticity is concerned (sometimes to
the despair of the classic photographers); there is a
gain when it enters into a dialogue with the informal
and ‘degraded’ images of new media to create a more
calibrated, therefore complex, connection with reality
and realism.
This new pop culture is
not only seen in visual culture but it reigns outside
from the ‘folk art to commercial film’ ‘from the
classical to fusion seen in music, dance and theater. This syndrome that hitherto defined the urban
popular in India. It is in a sense more homogeneous in
its purposes but requires diverse strategies and a
negotiating wit within the rubric of the ‘new’ media
deployed in the hard-sell of consumer commodities .
In music the term
‘fusion’ or
remixes is being used both in India and the West. In
India, more often than not, it meant Indian music,
which had been given a ‘rock’, or western ‘pop-music’
feel, as when Asha Bhonsle re-issued her old hit songs
to a disco beat and Susheela Raman, Trilok Gurti,
Nitin Sawhny generated amalgams of the east and west.
A new language became created in the world of music.
One of the most visible of these agents has been the
remarkable phenomenon of Bhangra, the emergence of
which is very much a part of the ongoing process of
cultural plurality. One of its extraordinary aspects
has been its ability to act as a pan- south Asian
music in the Diaspora. when club music across the
world features Bhangra pop. Bhangra, a generic term
for Punjabi music began as an Asian fusion music has
now entered mainstream, it is being heard in clubs
and coffeehouses such a the New York clubs and Berlin
coffee houses, emerging from it a new presentation a
new dominant strand of world music. This process of
hybridization is particularly apparent now in
developments within popular culture. The sociologist
Les Back describes the bhangramuffin music of the
singer/ songwriter Apache Indian as ‘a meeting place
where the languages and rhythms of the Caribbean,
North America and India mingle producing a new and
vibrant culture’. ‘Artists like Apache Indian are
expressing and defining cultural modes that are
simultaneously local and global.’ Back observes. ‘The
music manifests itself in a connective supplementarity
- raga plus Bhangra plus England plus
India plus Kingston plus Birmingham’.
With dance, and outside
India (in spite of discomfort with the word) ‘fusion’
was used to refer to any creative collaboration
between different cultures, such as when flamenco
dance met Kathak, or Zakir Hussein played a duet with
a Japanese shakuhachi flautist. As more and
more artists from Africa, South America, Asia, Europe
and the US began to interact in performance, the very
term ‘world music’, which before had referred to music
in general from non-western cultures, now suggested
cultural amalgams. The New York-based World Music
Institute increasingly promoted cross-cultural
encounters of which Indian musicians were often the
mainstay.
In India itself we find
a divide between the rhythms and synthesis in music
within the north south divide. The south which was
more Dravidian linked more to tribal music whereas
north India which was very hybrid, like ‘Vedic
Chants’, ‘Prabandh’, and subsequent additions with
central Asian and interface with Islamic traditions
where from pure ‘bholeh’ it spread to ‘Durbar’ leading
to a form of entertainment, a sensory makeover to
present day infotainment.
In theatre, the notion
of a ‘world theatre’
drawn from several different cultures grew. India with
its treasure of theatrical traditions had inspired
productions like Peter Brook’s Mahabharata and
Ariane Mnouchkine’s L’Indiade. Casts were
international, breaking down boundaries between
different ethnicities: a Nigerian played Bhima, a
Japanese actor was cast as Drona. The influence of
such productions led to more works, which incorporated
techniques, conventions - as well as actors - from
Indian theatre. A 1996 French production of Moliere’s
Tartuffe set in Turkey began with the
percussive sounds of a street vendor playing
Rajasthani khartaal. A 2000 Hamlet
featured three Indians out of a cast of eight.
Kathak meets club
dance, Indian dance went international when Uday
Shankar first performed with Anna Pavlova in the 20s.This collaborative gestures are
giving rise
to new trends in the history of dance where Mavin
Khoo and ballerina Sheena Chundee perform the
‘parrelel passions’. Shoban Jeyasingh uses
film projections within a stage work, using and
mixing contemporary music for her work, like that of
Micheal Nyman, Kevin Volansand Django Bates.
Jayachandran Palazhy uses Bharat Natyam and ballet and
taichi in his works. While Dakshat Seth creates a
work for the inauguration of the titan watch
factory, and in on of his pieces ‘Modern Times’ he
added funky and frivolous elements - baggy pants,
umbrellas, and walked like Chaplin
In the past two decades
of the twentieth century, a new movement began in
mass media with the work of South Asian diasporic
filmmakers in the West. Asian films no longer lurk
outside in the periphery but have entered the
mainstream, with the great success of the film by
British Asian filmmaker Gurinder Chadha released in
2002, ‘Bend It Like Beckham’. ‘Bombay Boys’ of Manoj
Night Shyamalan, Mira Nair’s ‘Monsoon Wedding’ become
hot favourites dealing with issues of dislocation of
identity and problems of identity fragmentation, the
splintering of culture into diverse sub- cultures, and
the clash of social values. Trying to reject the
‘westernizing’ influence of globalization and
attempting to cling on to or re- invent ‘traditional’
attitudes and ways of life. The world of cinema is
also reflecting this hybridization of cultures.
This process of fusion
is read even in Literature.
Literature in the postcolonial era, have common
concerns, their nations having all experienced
imperialism and colonization, and their peoples,
immigration and frequently more than once. Among the
common concerns there are: influences of colonization,
possibilities of decolonization and defining national
identity, power relations (between the colonizer and
the colonized, dominant group and minorities). As we
move from Indian subcontinent to the Caribbean, and
then to Canada, the diasporic writers (e.g.
Indian-Caribbean, African-Caribbean,
Indian-Caribbean-Canadian) help connect different
regions bringing about a global culture. Where culture
clash and metamorphosis is celebrated. V.S. Naipaul an
Indian by descent, a Trinidadian by birth, a Britain
by citizenship. He has lived in all three societies.
In His works is illustrated this concern of culture
conflict, issues concerning roots, gender, ethnicity,
caste. Celebrating hybridity. Roy's fictional canvas,
likewise, renders up a map of misrecognition. Her
unusually anti-picaresque heroine in The God of
Small Things, enacts a journey in reverse -- from
the cosmopolitan wholeness of America to the quiet
provincialism of Kerala
Hari Kunzru, in his
book 'Transmission' tells a story about men and women
tossed around by global forces that are beyond their
or for that matter, anyone's control or even
understanding. The impulse of the new generation is
sometimes money, sometimes sex or sometimes epidemic
the sense in which much postcolonial pedagogy is
participating in what Stanley Fish has called
“boutique multiculturalism”.
Anglo- Indian fiction
is experiencing a widely celebrated renaissance.
This seeming crossing
currents and moving towards reindexing the
international space. It is the ‘scene of
translations’. Beyond the demand for assimilation,
beyond absolutist notion of difference and identity,
beyond the reversible stances of ‘self’ and other in
which the euro centric gaze fashions itself as the
other, as the intoxicating exotic heady stuff of a
Smirnoff add - in the 1990s we have come to see the
international spaces as the meeting ground for a
multiplicity of tongues, visual grammar and style
Not only does this new
emergence in art practices give India a new reading
and making of art history, but it also creates a
bridge between the cultural divide. bringing in of a
new trajectory, while retaining its cultural
traditions. The Indian cultural sphere seems to be in
a debate between conservative and the liberal, the
revivalist and the progressive, the socialist and the
consumerist, the indigenist and the international A
Duality exists in India where the ancient and cyber-
space coexist. From a bowl of spiritual ideas,
Buddhism, Gandhi Vendatic thought Yoga it has become
the largest bowl of technological outsourcing, to
consumer markets. Confusion and clarity compete with
each other. In a world of dizzying technological
advancements, the Indian youth is searching to define
itself. The technological revolution has obliterated
time and distance, and transformed the present- day
into a global village, resulting in the blurring of
boundaries and the inclusion of foreignness either
culture. Rebellion and conformity form the two
extremes that challenge this generation. This energy
felt in the urban centers, is doubling at a rate which
is breathless.
In discussion are some
of the contemporary Indian artists who have resulted
from this complex east- west encounter, from this post
colonial, post modern trajectory. Experiencing a sense
of expanding horizons, at the same time being
confronted with a fresh range of cultural problems.
Modernity which started
with Raja Ravi Verma saw an embedding with and came to
stay with the west - east encounter. Amrita Shergil
with the werstern encounter and the eastern interpretation of the same brought to India all at
once a complex and dynamic complementarity of images.
Post colonial India saw an energy which valorized the
context of modernity with the progressives, where artists like F,N Souza,
S.H. Raza and other members
and associates of the progressive Artist Group helped
to give modern art in India an autonomous status. There
were artist who, in deference to the modernist
principle of condensation, the Baroda group, converted
lyric images into spiritual humans J. Swaminathan.,
Biren De to mane a few. At one end there was sustained
regard to indigenious, living traditions and to merge
the tradition /modernity aspects of contemporary
culture through a typically postcolonial eclecticism.
At the other end there was a desire to engage from the
overarching politics of the national by a reclusive
attention to formal choices that seemingly transcended
both cultural and subjective particularities and enter
the modernist frame.
Shantiniketan in a manner
stood alone was concerned with the ideas of
nationalism an indigenous modernity. They explored and
studied ancient and medieval traditions to create
indigenous alternatives to the Victorian academic realism with
the skeptical position of Ababnidranath Tagore through the first decades of the 20th century
to a more complex engagement that was developed by
Shantiniketan by Rabindranath Tagore, and taken over
at different levels of complexity by Nandalal Bose,
Ramkinker Baij and Benodbihari Mukherjee from the 30s
Shantiniketan brought through the ruse and reason of
indigenous subject- matter a methodological shift in
constructing the image. Taken up by Jamini Roy who
objectified the tradition by bringing folk iconicity
and urban commodification face to face. At the same
time Paris trained artist Amrita Shergil gave to this emerging
modernism a reflexive turn. By then Indian
art had begun to pose considerable formations on
modernism. A reckless manner of cultural symbiosis was
re enacted by the Bombay progressives. Together these artists
achieved in the first decade of independence
a positively modernist stance. Several artist group claiming modernism cam
into existence during the 40s
and 50s in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras.
The two enactments of
modernism were seen developing together in India.
Meanwhile there was a divergent in The Indian art
scene itself the Baroda artists like Jeram Patel, J.Swaminathan, Jyoti Bhatt responded to the European
modernists. The material, occult, ritual signs
reissued the modernist enterprise in the coming years.
It came to be situated with peculiar aptness in a visual
modernist vocabulary replete with metaphorical
illusions. But the surrounding rhetoric of Indianness
also grew apace in the 70s and 80s though all
tendencies were recycled within the Indian
sensibility.
Within the terms of a
post colonial transition, artistic eclecticism
corresponds to the polemic around Indian identity.
There were artist who made free use of tradition by
proffering mythic attributes and invested ancestral origins
in their work A Ramachandran, Ganesh Pyne,
Laxma Gouda, Manjit Bawa, Manu Parekh examples.
The terms national.
Secular, modern are so familiar in Indian cultural
discourse that modernism as such is not always
examined.,
A host of new avatars
descended quite suddenly on the sculptural ground. The
decade of the 90s saw the rise of many
representational tendency. making a dramatic rupture
with modernist conventions and offered a retake on
classical traditions.
The first retake eon the
sculptural trading came from Dhruva Mistry and Ravinder
Reddy, Reddys sculpture is about seduction, ornament,
gigantism, iconicity, repetition, fetish. Foxed with a
burning gaze he equates the eroticism in the divine
and popular, high and low traditions and thereby putting in a kitsch sublime.
N. N. Rimzon makes
traditional icons a noble pretext for radical
deviation. He directs the image, anthropomorphic or
symbolic, toward a material asceticism.
Shantiniketan
foregrounded the ideas of the rural over the urban, of
art as vocation as opposed to profession. They drew
upon an idealized fount of inspirational art. Particularly
in Nandalal Bose, Ramkinker and Benod
Bihari, saw a preference towards the rural and the folk, which set an agenda for a new romanticism in Indian
art. However, among the manifold contributions of Shantiniketan
we have examples of an indigenous modernism. We see here in an alternative strategy to
the modern, perhaps as a re assertion of values.
The Bengal school stood
alone taught at the early Indian schools went though
radical transformations from the 20s to 40s at
Shantiniketan
|